Sleep Training Your Breastfed Baby Without Hurting Milk Supply
- jaimiezaki
- Apr 25
- 4 min read
Updated: 4 days ago
If you thought I was going to tell you all about how to sleep train -- sorry for the click bait - but I know those are the words we've been taught & the words you're searching for.... but what you REALLY want, is answers to your sleep worries and struggles -- answers that solve problems AND sit right with your intuition while avoiding icky sleep training methods that are filled with stress for parents and baby. We're going to talk about using a gentle, baby led approach to sleep management so you can both improve your sleep & maintain your connection with your baby.
Table of Contents
Why Breastfeeding + Sleep Training Feels So Confusing
If you're desperate for more sleep but scared sleep training will mess up your milk supply, you're not alone. So many breastfeeding moms are told they have to pick one:Sleep Or breastfeeding success.
But it’s not either/or.
In this episode of the Breastfeeding With Confidence podcast, Jaimie Z. IBCLC and baby-led sleep expert Taylor McKay offer a better way: sleep that respects your baby’s needs and protects your supply.
Why Traditional Sleep Training Doesn’t Work for Breastfeeding Moms
Taylor learned the hard way—rigid sleep schedules didn’t work for her breastfed baby.
Why?
They ignored her baby's natural feeding rhythms
They led to frustration, tears, and a drop in supply
They clashed with her intuition
Breastfed babies have different sleep needs. Trying to fit them into mainstream sleep training molds often leads to more harm than help.
Are Night Wakings Really a Problem?
Nope. They’re actually normal and protective.
Taylor reminds us that:
Night wakings help maintain milk supply
They’re biologically normal for breastfed babies
Your baby’s waking is often their way of staying safe and connected
Instead of asking “How do I stop the night wakings?”—ask “What’s the purpose of this wake-up?”
Gentle Sleep Training That Protects Your Milk Supply
You can support better sleep without dropping night feeds or hurting your supply.
Taylor’s baby-led sleep method focuses on:
Honoring developmental readiness
Fixing feeding issues first
Promoting connection over separation
Result? Your baby sleeps better because they feel safe and secure—not because they’ve been trained to stop asking for you.
The Secret to Better Sleep? Emotional + Physical Connection
A baby who feels connected to you during the day is more likely to settle at night.
Especially if you're a working mom, focus on:
One-on-one time during the day
Gentle, calm bedtime routines
Nursing as comfort—not a crutch
Breastfeeding + bonding = better sleep (without cry-it-out tactics).
Co-Sleeping + Sleep Spaces: What’s Best for Breastfeeding Moms?
There’s no one-size-fits-all here.
You have options.
✔️ Safe co-sleeping can support frequent night nursing
✔️ Room-sharing makes feedings easier
✔️ Independent sleep can work—if baby feels ready and secure
You can transition without guilt, or weaning.
Handling Sleep Changes Without Losing Your Mind (or Supply)
Sleep transitions are hard—on you and your baby. Taylor’s tip?
Expect some tears
Be present, not perfect
Don’t rush or shut down emotions
Gentle support keeps your breastfeeding bond strong and helps baby feel safe.
Beware the “12 hours by 12 Weeks” Culture
The truth? Most of these methods are built for bottle-fed, sleep-trained babies.
They're not designed for:
Breastfeeding rhythms
Biological norms
Long-term bonding
Sleep training that ignores your intuition, connection, and milk supply isn’t worth it.
Yes, You Can Sleep Train Without Weaning or Hurting Supply
It’s not about rigid schedules. It’s about balance.
Taylor’s baby-led approach helps you:
Understand your baby’s unique needs
Protect your milk supply
Get more rest without losing your breastfeeding bond
Final Takeaway: Trust Yourself
Your instinct matters.
If something feels off, it probably is.If a sleep plan tells you to ignore cries, stop night nursing, or wean early—it’s not for you.
Instead:
Zoom out and see the big picture
Know that night nursing isn’t forever
Trust that you’re the expert on your baby
Need Support for Baby Sleep + Breastfeeding?
Check out Taylor McKay at @cozylittlesleepers on Instagram. She offers personalized support and workshops designed for breastfeeding families.
Jaimie Zaki is an International Board Certified Lactation Consultant (IBCLC) and mom of 5! Jaimie has volunteered as a La Leche League Leader, worked as a nurse, doula, and birth photographer, and is the host of the Breastfeeding With Confidence Podcast and founder of the Confident MamaBear Society. Jaimie provides holistic breastfeeding advice for pregnant & new moms, helping them overcome unexpected latching trouble and milk supply issues. She empowers mothers to make informed decisions from a place of confidence and intuition.
Breastfeeding Resources Available:
